> It looks great, but to me this is pretty much the opposite of what I want to use - the demo video at least is so busy, and full of transitions and other distractions.
They are optional: you can make them last 100 ms, or just remove them.
Such "eyecandy" enable new uses: for example, all my windows are full screen, on they own desktop. No titlebar, no nothing because that's a waste of space. A quick animation when I change desktop helps me keep a mental map.
Also, hyprland great strength is it makes it not just possible but very easy to have a keyboard-centric workflow: you mix the tiling window manager strength with the traditional "windows" you can move with your mouse. F1 gets me to desktop 1 where my terminals live, Shift+F1 can send whatever window I'm using on desktop 1 to share it with the terminal for a while, Win + Left lets me adjust the tiling and Win + J lets me change from horizontal to vertical tiling
Last year was my year of Linux on the desktop, and I think I'll stay on Linux if only for hyprland.
> I have a weird urge to write a Frankencompositor that supports Wayland clients and enough to support an out-of-band X11 style window manager and the brutally insecure X11 style event snooping and injection; partly because it'd really irritate some Wayland purists
Check hyprctl: you can get a list of windows. With hyprland key bindings + basic shell scripts using hyprctl and ydotool to send key or mouse events, it's already possible!
From one of my simple scripts: `hyprctl dispatch focuswindow $WINDOW_ID | wl-paste | wl-copy -c` replaced `ydotool type "`wl-paste`"`
> They are optional: you can make them last 100 ms, or just remove them.
I'd rather have a codebase that doesn't have them so that I can work on a codebase that is tiny and focused on what I want when I want to change something. And I would need to make changes to the code base for it to suit me - see below.
> Also, hyprland great strength is it makes it not just possible but very easy to have a keyboard-centric workflow:
I already have a keyboard-centric workflow that does the things you list. There's nothing new in any of that. I have a floating desktop; I can move and resize them with the keyboard. I can move the tiling windows with the keyboard. I can swap individual windows, or swap entire subtrees, or flip their direction. All of that is trivial on almost any tiling wm.
> Check hyprctl: you can get a list of windows. With hyprland key bindings + basic shell scripts using hyprctl and ydotool to send key or mouse events, it's already possible!
This has the same flaw that was one of the reasons why I ditched bspwm - it allows getting events from it's 2nd socket - but not to intercept requests and being able to rewrite and choose whether to honor the requests or not. It does not have the flexibility I had in mind.
It has a lot of great functionality, but none of the things that I care about provide more than I already have, and some would set me back to the point I'd have to rewrite stuff again - and frankly just the build process for hyprland makes me break out in hives...
They are optional: you can make them last 100 ms, or just remove them.
Such "eyecandy" enable new uses: for example, all my windows are full screen, on they own desktop. No titlebar, no nothing because that's a waste of space. A quick animation when I change desktop helps me keep a mental map.
Also, hyprland great strength is it makes it not just possible but very easy to have a keyboard-centric workflow: you mix the tiling window manager strength with the traditional "windows" you can move with your mouse. F1 gets me to desktop 1 where my terminals live, Shift+F1 can send whatever window I'm using on desktop 1 to share it with the terminal for a while, Win + Left lets me adjust the tiling and Win + J lets me change from horizontal to vertical tiling
Last year was my year of Linux on the desktop, and I think I'll stay on Linux if only for hyprland.
> I have a weird urge to write a Frankencompositor that supports Wayland clients and enough to support an out-of-band X11 style window manager and the brutally insecure X11 style event snooping and injection; partly because it'd really irritate some Wayland purists
Check hyprctl: you can get a list of windows. With hyprland key bindings + basic shell scripts using hyprctl and ydotool to send key or mouse events, it's already possible!
From one of my simple scripts: `hyprctl dispatch focuswindow $WINDOW_ID | wl-paste | wl-copy -c` replaced `ydotool type "`wl-paste`"`