Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Because announcing a coup in advance is stupendously idiotic?

Ina traditional coup on MONDAY at 3 am soldiers roll into the TV stations and various government buildings. They announcing a change of government and people turn up to work Monday morning.

On Friday evening?! They must be copying the failed Turkey coup that had to move forwards because they were uncovered.




> a traditional coup on MONDAY at 3 am soldiers roll into the TV stations and various government buildings

This is a military coup. The army is in Zaporizhia. Moscow is defended by the FSB and national guard. Prigozhin needs to rally disgruntled forces to his side to enable him to move his troops. Quietly maneuvering would hand the narrative to the regime.


Well I for one am biting the bullet and getting Netflix multiscreen 4K.

Might as well see the world end in style.


Why would a military coup attempt in Russia cause the world to end?


> The army is in Zaporizhia

Ah, yes, all 3 regiments, none left in Moscow.


UK MoD estimated earlier in the year that 97% of the Russian Army was deployed to Ukraine.

The 1st Guards Tank Army, which includes the elite units traditionally tasked with Moscow's defense, the 2nd Guards Motor Rifle Division and the 4th Guards Tank Division has been heavily committed in Ukraine for most of the war.

There is a defensive plan activated and deployment of forces in Moscow, sure, but Wagner has a lot of troops and combat experience, and what Russia has kept available at home mostly aren’t regular army troops, but Nationa Guard troops mainly used for intimidating civilians.


> 97% of the Russian Army

3% is not enough to keep the lights in a country this big.

It's no question where are the most but 3%? Doubt it.


And UK would say the truth?


> yes, all 3 regiments, none left in Moscow

Nobody said Moscow is undefended. Just less able to defend itself than usual. Much of the Russian Western military district is deployed towards Ukraine. Sensibly, Putin’s most loyal should have been held back. But the war is going terribly. If his loyalists were forward deployed, that changes the calculus.


> Because announcing a coup in advance is stupendously idiotic?

There are different kinds of blows directed at leadership that work primarily by surprise seizure or elimonation of key personnel and/or facilities, perhaps the most traditional “military coup”.

There are mass mutinies by military formations, which are essentially armed direct-action protests by troops, often under their established leadership. A sizable formation declaring them and calling on others to join is not at all unheard of. Functionally, they can succeed as a form of coup or half-coup (replacing the top leadership or forcing concessions) while retaining the basic state infrastructure, or end up as a key part of a more complete revolution (or, obviously, just fail). They are a very real historical thing.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: