Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

SNL must be like bad quality candy that is so part and parcel of one's childhood that one can never quite outgrow it or fail to not cherish it, despite now knowing that nearly candy from any other part of the world has superior, wholesome and more nourishing ingredients than the HFCS-sweetened, off-tasting, peanut-packed kind - the only kind - you've known growing up.

For the most part - and with the exception of unintended humor owing to the broadcasted-live nature of the show - I've never really found SNL to be very funny or talented or thought-provoking. I never quite got what the fuss was all about.




It is mostly bad, but occasionally they do something good; I would call this one example of that. Not worth sitting through the whole show, but the better bits can be found on YouTube or NBC's site.


The good stuff will come to you, you'll read about it at Salon or Buzzfeed or see it trending on Twitter.


I largely agree, even the skits that are considered all time classics fall a bit flat for me. (I'm sorry in advance, but the cowbell sketch comes to mind).

There have definitely been occasional hits, though.


Grew up watching shitty 70's game shows. The "Charades" SNL parody was so dead-on ... I cried.

https://youtu.be/lIkQjUMOnmc


Well, it’s much closer to improv than your standard scripted television comedy. Whatcha going to do - sketch is a niche comedy style.


to be fair, they have only a few days to create each episode. that's a fantastic amount of work. it's not like they can just download a JS framework and bang out something over a weekend.


Okay, which weekly live sketch show do you prefer?

For me, the virtues of SNL are that Weekend Update usually has good topical jokes, and once in a while there's a sketch like "Potato Chip" or "Monkey Judge".


Sadly, we’re not all as smart as you.


Phew, if this is the outlook of one after becoming "that smart", I'm happy being a mindless dolt in comparison. Guilty pleasures in life are a good thing


Well, the original commenter clearly seems to think so. Whether that's in any way true or not is left as an exercise for the reader.


tl;dr: I don't like SNL.

Cool, bro.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: