Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

wtbob's comment being downvoted is kind of proof in itself.



I don't see how.


My train of thought was following: 1. vote result represents opinion of "masses" 2. the comment in question says "masses of people need a clear, obvious Right Thing" 3. the comment itself is not clear and obvious as it contains double bind (asks to consider to be inconsiderate) 4. comment got downvoted which confirms #2

Just our of curiosity I've replied with another double bind "downvotes proof comment worthiness" which seems have reversed the trend.

Speaking on topic, I think that choosing between Right Thing and Full Picture for the "masses" is like choosing between acceleration and breaks for a car: it is better to have both. Right Thing mobilizes masses while Full Picture helps to avoid dumb aggression.


Good break down regarding your own comment




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: