Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

What about purgatory?



Over 12 years of Catholic education I was taught that the whole concept of purgatory had been repudiated. But looking it up now, it seems to have been resuscitated, albeit as a sort of "waiting period" for souls that hadn't fully reconciled with God.

In any case, at least in the modern Church, the concept of purgatory isn't an endorsement of the benefits of suffering.


Have you ever considered the possibility that for over 12 years of Catholic education, you were being lied to, and that many of the things you devoutly believe without question are simply not true?

Case in point: your false beliefs that fly in the face of all the evidence (much of it from their own doctrine, statements and actions) that the Catholic Church believes and preaches that sin is atoned for with suffering. Haven't you ever heard of that guy named "Jesus"? Isn't there a commandment that says you're not supposed to lie?

Penn and Teller and Christopher Hitchens certainly make a strong case that the Catholic Church and Mother Teresa and Bill Donohue are obsessed with suffering and totally full of Bullshit. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o6voAW_Go5Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-UR-0Kdff4M


I am not Catholic, but to assert that he devoutly believes things without question is a big assertion.

For myself, to believe something I question it first. We should extend the same courtesy to others - they surely question things first.


[flagged]


You're clearly passionate about this topic. I can practically feel the flecks of spittle hitting my face as I read your comment.


Well you should learn more about your own religion before spreading misinformation about it.


Well, you've sure persuaded me.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: