Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

As someone else said, different breeds are very different in behaviors, and it's not as simple as you make it out in any way, shape, or form.



Wouldn't consideration for others, then, compel people to choose quieter breeds if they live in close proximity to other people?


So some dogs simply don't belong in public spaces. It's the owners that bring them there.


A bad dog is the fault of a bad owner. You should try watching Cesar Millan sometime.


It's not about "bad dog" or "good dog", it's "your dog doesn't belong in the grocery store sniffing the lettuce I'm trying to buy", or "your dog doesn't belong in the clothing store shedding hair all over the pants I'm trying to buy".

Neither are things that a "good dog" wouldn't do or a "bad dog" would, they're both natural things that the dog can't help... ie. it's not the dog's fault it's shedding.

The problem is the owner that invites the situation.

It's just plain rude for the owner to think everyone else has to put up with their animal. I love animals, always have (since I was a kid I've never not owned a cat or dog, or both, sometimes multiples of both), but I would never think it sane to force my animal upon others, especially at a store.


Beagles that bark, or labradors that sniff everything, are not bad dogs.

You can't breed behaviors into dogs for 100+ years, and then claim it's the owners fault the dogs do it.

I'd believe some dogs you can get them to overcome their instincts, but even that is quite difficult.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: