Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It's hardly 'long-forgotten'...

From Körner's book 'Fourier Analysis' (CUP, 1988):

"[...] Kelvin ... designed and built a ... machine (the harmonic analyser) to perform the task 'which seemed to the Astronomer Royal so complicated and difficult that no machine could master it' of computing the coefficients from the record of the past height [of tides].

Kelvin's harmonic analyser has a good claim to be the grandfather of today's computers not only because he obtained government money to build it but also because it represents the first major victory in the struggle 'to substitute brass for brain' in calculation. It is pleasant to record that Kelvin's instruments were so well adapted to their purpose that it took electronic computers 20 years to replace them.' - p.30-1

and

'We have seen ... how Kelvin invented machines which could compute periodic functions from their Fourier series and conversely obtain the Fourier series of a given periodic function. One such machine was constructed by Michelson to work to a higher accuracy and to involve many more terms that previous models. (Michelson's ability to build and operate equipment to new standards of accuracy was legendary. Of his interferometer which he invented and used in the Michelson Morley experiments it was said that it was a remarkable instrument - provided you had Michelson to operate it. His experiments to measure the diameter of the nearest stars using an interferometer were not reproduced for 30 years.)" - p.62




I love Körner's book: it is amazing, interesting, accurate, his personality shines through . . . . I spent quite a bit of time with it when we had debates about some of the technical issues underlying the machine. This book likely isn't the place to start your study of fourier methods, but it is THE place to end!


>Of his interferometer which he invented and used in the Michelson Morley experiments it was said that it was a remarkable instrument - provided you had Michelson to operate it. His experiments to measure the diameter of the nearest stars using an interferometer were not reproduced for 30 years.

From the perspective of the scientific method ("on the words of no one" etc), that's ... not actually a good thing.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: