Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> it's a proprietary Apple system

Yes, that's true.

> that you can't get your data out of without their blessing

No, that is not true.




I genuinely don't know, I develop in Windowsland and what I'm going on is what I read in this thread. A post above said:

if you're downloading software from outside the app store then you can't be angry that those packages aren't allowed to talk to iCloud- probably (and I'm speculating) each binary is signed when it leaves the app store so it's allowed to talk to iCloud

and

I don't expect my Linux machine to be able to access iCloud

which suggest that there is something specific about this that locks the user into Apple hardware and software.

Is getting a Linux machine to talk to it just a matter of reverse-engineering the protocol, or is there more to it?


I'm just saying there is a difference between a proprietary system and needing a company's "blessing" to get data out of it.

If I save bookmarks in IE on Windows 8, I can only sync that data with another Windows 8 machine. That doesn't mean I need Microsoft's blessing to do so--just one or more of their products--which anyone can buy on the open market.


Firefox and Chrome will sync my bookmarks to any device I use. Safari and IE will not. I will not buy an iOS or WinRT device.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: