Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Absolutely nothing.

It's Totalitarianism, nothing more or less.




I just can't understand how the people who work in there do not see it.


I worked in the defense industry for a few years (1998-2002). I didn't see it at the time. Everyone works in isolation, no one talks about work and everyone is micromanaged to bits and separately motivated. It's heavily draped in propaganda as well, most of which is horse shit. It's all much like the promoted status of imperialist armies.

Obviously september 11th 2001 happened and to see your colleagues actually see that as job security and a way to sell more weapons and celebrate that turned it for me. I started to question the ethics of what I was doing and decided it was best that I left. I bailed one afternoon, gave no notice and spent three months selling Sun kit on ebay before taking a job at a web agency selling whiskey and houses instead.

Most people didn't get that "moment" and are still prisoners of the inane propaganda. The same is true of those at GCHQ.

My children are doing GCHQ sponsored mathematics work (cryptography challenges) at the age of 10 probably in the vain hope that they will eventually see this as normal and be recruited before they have a chance to question the ethics of it all.


>My children are doing GCHQ sponsored mathematics work (cryptography challenges) at the age of 10 probably in the vain hope that they will eventually see this as normal and be recruited before they have a chance to question the ethics of it all.

What? Care to elaborate? (I'm American if that explains why I have no idea what you are referring to)


Well it goes like this....

There was a lot of publicity and propaganda and hype around Alan Turing and cyber-security over the last few years in the UK media. This drove a whole codebreaking fascination thing with mathematics.

So not wishing to miss out on all the action, a project was started called The Enigma Project which features basic codebreaking challenges (basic substitution ciphers, OTP etc) aimed at primary school children. This was started by Simon Singh / Cambridge University after good old Si released a book called The Code Book after which he wanted to drum up publicity rapidly. No other reason.

So after a year or so of neglect these sheets work their way into "photocopy circulation" amongst schools in the UK as part of the typical "teachers don't give a shit and just want to hand out worksheets" culture that appeared.

Obviously any other material that could be assembled cheaply was chucked on the back. Turns out there's a couple of sheets plainly marked from GCHQ in there as well as "additional exercises". Rather interesting as they are above what you'd consider appropriate for that age (prime factorisation and rapid factorisation techniques etc). Very odd!

Now this in itself is pretty null and void but it leads into the culture which I experienced where we were asked in secondary school mathematics to enter various "challenges" to play off against other schools. I was pretty good at mathematics (at GCSE and A-level) and did well on these challenges but was approached after this by people recruiting for SIGINT rather than go to university. Other people who did well were similarly propositioned. I impolitely declined and relaxed into a life of electrical engineering, pizza and beer which I thoroughly don't regret.

I'm worried my children will be similarly filtered out and recruited to be honest.


Really interesting (if a bit disturbing, to be honest). Thanks for sharing.


The United States defense agencies also run and sponsor mathematics contests and summer program(s) for students. For example, the NSA sponsors the USA Mathematical Talent Search, the Office of Naval Research sponsors MOSP, the "Department of Defense" is listed for MathCOUNTS.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: