Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I see this a lot in NSA topics about how some new legal challenge might reverse NSA activities... Why does anyone think this will work? The NSA is accountable to the executive. The executive is responsible for enforcing laws but can selectively enforce... Why would it limit it's own power?



Checks and balances. The NSA is funded by Congress. Congress needs the courts in order for their legislation to have any effect.


Intelligence agencies have a history of attempting to circumvent the limitations imposed by funding. There's a lot of evidence that the CIA has been involved in drug trafficking. In the case of the NSA, it could for example sell some of its intel to the private sector (technical and business information concerning rival companies).


that's the long game. the KGB basically became the Russian Mafia when the USSR went under. maybe the NSA's thinking ahead too.


So what do you think it is in this case? Front running? Or a more esoteric form of market manipulation?


Bitcoin, obviously.


Not a lawyer but one reason may be that the activities are in a legal grey area where they have secret interpretations of laws. They work hard to keep cases that involve these interpretations out of the courts because as soon as a judge declares it illegal they must stop. Kind of like asking for forgiveness rather than permission.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: