Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Ask PG: When do we get the email/call?
10 points by nextmoveone on Oct 18, 2007 | hide | past | favorite | 15 comments
Do we get the Yay or Nay at 12 tonight? or later tomorrow?



Do not ask "When?". Instead ask yourself "What is time?" ;)


Juan Pablo, do you live in Miraflores? Or where? I have family all over Lima.


Yes, I actually live in Miraflores! (Did I mention it somewhere?)

So, are you peruvian?


Your profile says Lima, Peru... a lot of people live in Miraflores so...

But, I'm American, my mother and grandparents are Peruvian.

Do you have AIM or email?


juanpablo dot scaletti at gmail

it works as IM too



So, is that just sometime tomorrow?


Sometime tomorrow. Trevor and Robert haven't finished voting yet. Then we have to get together and argue about the borderline cases. We'll probably send out emails in the evening.


Speaking of arguing about borderline cases -- have there been instances where you (or other YC principals) have gone ahead and funded applicants personally when you haven't managed to convince everyone else that they deserve to be funded by YC?

I suppose this is really a question about how much you're committed to doing things as a group -- if the YC process is anything like assessment processes I've been involved in (e.g., deciding who gets honourary degrees from my university) there must be instances where a minority thinks that an application is exceptional but can't convince other people of this.


No, but more because the money is not the important part than because we feel like we always have to act as a group.


Thanks -- I should have realized that while any one of you could fund an application which you liked, no one of you could provide all the other YC-related advantages without all the other YC principals agreeing.


I appreciate the feedback, thanks!


An experience of working with YC who has got people so transparent will be a dream come true (if selected, ofcourse!)


Thanks for such transparency.


For two cycles ago, I got the interview invite at 23 Oct 2006 16:55:00.

The rejection last cycle I got at 10 Apr 2007 21:05:49.




Consider applying for YC's W25 batch! Applications are open till Nov 12.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: