Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I'm intrigued by Jolla, if not enthused by it.

I'm not sure what it gives me that Android doesn't - can anyone enlighten me?




It depends on what you are interested in. Distinctive features:

1. It has strong focus on real multitasking (performance and design wise). Both Android and iOS are weak on that and prefer to avoid multitasking in order to gain battery life advantage.

2. It has innovative approach to UI, not being stuck in ideas developed a while ago, which hold Android and iOS back from advancing.

3. It's DRM free and aims to be privacy respecting unlike competition. It gives control over the system to the user and doesn't attempt to lock things up and make it hard to modify.

4. For those who care (developers probably more than others) - it's real glibc based Linux which gives synergy with the global Linux community. Android while using the Linux kernel is a completley different beast from libc and middleware up to the top of the stack. Mer/Sailfish on the other hand uses glibc, Wayland and other conventional Linux middleware and tools.

5. They plan to allow better participation of community in the development. Right now things aren't so open though, except the open parts Sailfish is based on (Mer Core and Nemo Mobile which are openly developed open source projects).

6. It's a startup and not some monstrous stonewalling corp with no face. So you often can communicate with Jolla directly (they even have official presence in Diaspora: https://joindiaspora.com/u/jolla) and they are interested in the community.

For more details see:

* https://sailfishos.org/about.html

* https://sailfishos.org/design.html

* https://wiki.merproject.org/wiki/Main_Page

* https://wiki.merproject.org/wiki/Nemo


Thank you, that's really useful.


In the same boat. It runs on mostly the same broad hardware (as I understand it leveraging much of the Android BSP work via libhybris). Obviously if you prefer Qt to Java/Dalvik it's a win, but the fact that it includes the Android runtime means that most app developers are going to target Android anyway.

It's sort of a wash from the perspective of open source. The SailfishOS core seems more open and "project-like" than AOSP, but just like with Google/GMS the core apps and user-facing bits are proprietary to Jolla. And being new, the ecosystem doesn't yet have good open source replacements you can find for Android.


Here is some material from the launch event last year: http://bergie.iki.fi/blog/jolla-sailfish/


What do you think Jolla is?




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: