Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I live in India & I agree - there is horrendous amount of corruption. And the unique identification number project might not change anything when it comes to illegal immigrants, terrorists.

However as the article highlights this would give me one power for which I am okay to bear the grunt of privacy issues: I can (at least proactively) ensure my identity is not misused & if it is, I can at least be aware of it - stop it & probably dig in more.

Right now I have a ration card which is particularly necessary to get a cooking gas connection (which btw is of scarce availability - again corruption). There might be a person living at my native or hometown who is aware I am not availing the facility and probably using a duplicate card or something. There is no system to quickly check if this is happening. With the new initiative I hope it would be difficult to duplicate & easy to track. At the least these processes will get digitized the right way, given Nilekani is heading it & not yet another uneducated/ corrupt politician.

Edit: phrase correction.




> Right now I have a ration card which is particularly necessary to get a cooking gas connection

Let me suggest that your problem is not the lack of an ID card but rationing.


My problem is the misuse of facilities that is happening in the country where I live.


If you disagree please tell me why. not blindly down vote.

I avoided being rude for a "suggestion" which was not solicited nor rational let alone appropriate.


I didn't downvote you, but my suggestion was both rational and appropriate. Identifying the actual problem is always a good idea.

As to whether it was solicited, commenting in HN is a request for comments. That's what the reply link means.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: