Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Erm. People have been eating meat on a regular, frequent basis only very recently in History. 60 years ago it was meat just one a month or something. And people didn't just die off because they couldn't eat meat anymore.



That's simply not true. Inuit have almost exclusively eaten meat for centuries. And there are parts of the world where agriculture and irrigation don't work and animals which can feed on scrub are the staple.


Well, I was talking about Europe, mainly, and I assume in most countries of the developed word this was very much the same. I don't think Inuits have very much to do with the industrial production of meat we have nowadays, do they ?


Actually, I believe the Inuit don't practice animal husbandry either; they mainly get their food from the ocean (mostly as meat).


It is, at least in Europe. Ask your grandparents and they will tell you that they maybe ate meat once a week


Here's one of the big the reason.

Meat requires a lot of space to grow!

Europe is small, and there isn't a lot of extra space. Less meat.

Enter the United States. WOAH! Lots of land! More space to raise meat! More meat!

NPR mentioned another factor a while back in their program, "The making of meat eating America," American innovation.

http://www.npr.org/blogs/thesalt/2012/06/26/155720538/the-ma...

Almost two centuries ago, he says, meat was one reason why immigrants found America so amazing. "When the Irish come in the 1840s, they write letters back saying 'I eat meat every day,'" Horowitz says. "And they get letters back saying, 'You must be kidding. It can't be true.'"

Back in Europe, says Horowitz, the growing of livestock was often organized and regulated in a way that funneled meat straight to the wealthy or the landed aristocracy. In the new world, though, meat was much easier to find. Grazing lands were close to cities; sometimes . Farmers quickly realized that raising animals was a good business. Cities set up markets for them. "And the result is a flourishing of the livestock industry, very early in American history."

As a result, when new technology came along, like railroads and refrigeration, American entrepreneurs were able to jump right in and use it to turn beef into a centralized, national industry.

"Why could they sell chilled beef in New York in the 1880s? Because New Yorkers had been getting beef in their markets and butcher shops for at least a hundred years. So we have this new meat coming in? It's a little cheaper, let's give it a try!" Horowitz says.

That's been the story ever since: , more efficient meat production, and Americans kept saying — "Hey, it's a little cheaper, let's give it a try!"


What? I'm Irish and my grandparents ate meat, fish or eggs pretty much every day of their lives


Then your grandparents were unusually wealthy. My grandparents certainly didn't.


Or perhaps you're just older, so your grandparents were from a different generation?


Well not in the post WW2 germany my grandparents lived in.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: