Content is not just culture, it is also entertainment. Indeed, the kind of conte...

nitrogen · on March 20, 2013

The discussion about culture in the context of DRM is far from "handwaving." Culture and entertainment have always been intertwined; don't let high culture snobs tell you otherwise.

pasbesoin · on March 20, 2013

I agree. I think the GP is tackling an artificial construct / separation.

In fact, these days I think of much communication, including "entertainment", as "cultural programming".

As such, it and its use (and citation, reuse, refactoring...) are central to our lives and to society's development (or lack thereof).

rayiner · on March 20, 2013

Yes, Gears of War is "central to our lives and to society's development."

The vast majority of the content protected by DRM is morally indistinguishable from acts at a strip club--pure, base, entertainment. And I don't see many people calling for those to be free, even though it costs a strip club owner nothing to let extra people look in through the window (i.e. zero marginal cost of reproduction).

pasbesoin · on March 21, 2013

Have you noticed how... "mainstream" porn stars have become in the last decade (at least, in U.S. society/media)?

Whether or not one agrees with a particular element, I think such influences are significant.

And, to extent this point a bit further and perhaps offer a contrasting viewpoint, for all the "objectification" of women that this prevalence may be promoting -- and I'm not saying there aren't some fairly pernicious influences, in this regard -- it also seems to be shaking off some of the cultural taboos about speaking openly about sex.

The outcome of such influences is not simple.

And being able to dialog about them is essential to understanding them. Which includes access that is not overly, artificially constrained. And which includes citation and reuse within the arts, for example. As well, in reporting, peer-to-peer (e.g. sharing game play videos), etc.

Once such influences have been released into culture, I don't agree with a private party having an exclusive hand on the spigot to just turn off access to and so informed conversation about such influences.

Reasonable compensation is one matter. Control of cultural dialog is another.

mikecane · on March 21, 2013

>>>Indeed, the kind of content that is protected by DRM is mostly entertainment, and not very much culture.

Did you ever go see a Batman movie? A Superman movie? Iron Man? The Avengers movie? Those weren't considered "culture" as recently as the 1970s. Stop.