Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Bleh.

I may as well respond by bringing up the mother of three who works 12 hour shifts at walmart was expelled from highschool and never had even the most basic idea of food preparation or culinary training. I suppose she should simply 'bootstrap up' like the rest of us did when we were in that situation. Hah, oh that's right, the vast majority here are college educated and in the top 15% of income earners.

This gets us nowhere. It's a circular argument that has been done to death.

If you want to argue that I (me personally) should know better, absolutely, if you want to argue someone in the bottom 50% should know better then go volunteer at a shelter.




Whoa!

In my country people who have never been to school or even know what a school is, ordinary farm labor workers or daily wage workers involved in construction work. Or people who work as a push cart vendors or name any low level work(Which probably you don't even know in the US exists) perfectly cook their own food and feed themselves.

But somehow in the US you need to go to Stanford to learn how to cook!


Or: in the US (and Europe, and other "developed" countries) you don't have to go to any school at all to learn that whenever you can blame a big company, that trumps any requirement for having sense.

For instance, take http://www.telegraph.co.uk/foodanddrink/foodanddrinknews/921...

You actually need someone to take care of you so that you can't drink 9 litres of Coke per day, and if you do, the Coca-Cola Company is responsible?

I blame consumer protection laws, which have gone too far in some things. (In others, they haven't gone far enough.)


I don't think you need to be a top 15% earner to know to stop eating when you're full.


Did you read the article? If so I'd focus in on the "vanishing caloric density" section (and the rest of it too).

Not saying you don't have a good point, but it's not as mindlessly easy as you make it seem.


I don't think it's mindlessly easy--if it were, nobody would be obese. I just don't think American obesity demands a conspiracy theory or a lot of outrage to be explained. It's adequately explained by: there's no shortage of food and greatly diminished need for physical exertion.


Why can't it be some of everything? What you said in your comment, unhealthy foods being the cheapest and easiest, and these foods not causing satiety when eaten.


It can be some of everything, but some of everything sort of undermines the conspiracy theory, don't you think?


Actually, you should stop eating before being full. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hara_hachi_bu


Let me know how many calories of Coca Cola it takes to make you full.


Let me know how many times you've been forced to drink a Coke at gunpoint.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: