Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Your comment is a manifestation of this weird double standard that gets applied to atheists/agnostics where they’re supposed to be burdened to “find answers” and it’s a problem that they don’t have that religious burden.

It also manifests in this sort of insulted vibe that religious people get when their faith is questioned.

Basically, it’s socially not okay to question the faith of someone in a particular religion because it’s their culture, it’s their belief system, but the atheist/agnostic “belief” system isn’t respected in the same way. The person who has not found any evidence of god as described in various religions is told to seek enlightenment as if they are the ones who are incomplete.

People who use the scientific method don’t “pick at random” when there is no available answer. They test for answers and wait until they observe the answers and have the ability to reproduce those observations.

In short, the religious expect the non-religious to be afraid of dying and to be looking for a solution, when it’s completely valid and logical to have determined that there is no solution and therefore it is not worth spending time dwelling upon.




i expects everyone who questions any religion to do that search. whether they believe in god or not. if you question something, then it is on you to go find answers. even if you found your belief system that works for you. maybe especially if you found one you should always keep your eyes open and investigate your own beliefs, and not just blindly accept it.


This is still kind of backwards. The person who doesn’t accept something blindly has no obligation to question anything. There is no obligation to obtain a belief system. Someone who is agnostic is not blindly accepting anything.


The person who doesn’t accept something blindly has no obligation to question anything

not accepting something blindly IS the same as questioning something. or reverse, if you do not question your beliefs then you are accepting them blindly.

There is no obligation to obtain a belief system

i didn't say there is, except maybe that rejecting all belief systems is also a kind of belief.

Someone who is agnostic is not blindly accepting anything.

again, i didn't intend to make that claim. if anything that was more targeted at those who do follow a particular religion and stopped asking questions.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: