Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

That ship has sailed with technology in general.

Sure, it isn't safe for EU governments to store data on US clouds.

It also isn't safe for US governments to rely on chips made in Taiwan that China could invade. Or for TikTok to be a primary media source in the US.

The fact is, we're an economically interconnected world at this point, in terms of software, in terms of hardware, and in terms of hardware supply chains.

And it's hard to see it going backwards. Economic efficiency is a powerful force. It often seems like the solution has to be to try to implement as many safeguards as possible, rather than cut off sources of technology. But I don't know... it's an incredibly difficult question.




There’s an old civics aphorism: if goods don’t cross borders, then armies will.

Giving all your data to foreign states though may be a bridge too far. That’s not the same as buying cars or Swedish Fish.


> Giving all your data to foreign states though may be a bridge too far.

Does it really matter?

If large Western countries want to spy on each other, there are so many ways via so many devices.

That's why I'm talking about safeguards -- why not just focus on ensuring everything is encrypted in rest and in transit, so you can use anybody's cloud anywhere?


Supply lines. You offer political asylum to someone I don’t like I can shut your entire federal government down to get him.


That's an act of war.

Fortunately, going multi-cloud is a thing. Storing data with multiple providers in multiple countries. Lots of companies which specialize in multi-cloud solutions.

Again, like I said -- safeguards.


Gonna be a very short war.


And if you're dumb enough to put your government clouds in enemy countries, then you deserve it.

But we're not talking about enemy countries here, now are we? Or are you actually under the impression that we're talking about hosting data in Iran and North Korea...?


I don't know if you've been watching politics for the last 4 months...


I don't know if you understand the concept of military enemy and how it differs from countries that are simply cooperating less...




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: