Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It's a little sad to see CRTs withering into nothingness. The devices just don't last. The glass is obviously fragile. But even if you keep it padded and safe, the coils of the deflection yoke are thin magnet wire operated at high voltage, and after decades of thermal cycles and the resulting rubbing eventually the barrier between two drops enough and they short, catastrophically.

And you can't really repair that in any feasible way. There are hundreds or thousands of windings, which have to duplicate exactly the configuration from the factory (and then probably be calibrated by processes that are lost to history). A dead CRT is just a useless hunk of glass, forever.

They're all dying. And that's kind of sad.






> But even if you keep it padded and safe, the coils of the deflection yoke are thin magnet wire operated at high voltage

The coils in the deflection yoke are run at 24-100V.

The acceleration voltage is the high voltage one.

> There are hundreds or thousands of windings, which have to duplicate exactly the configuration from the factory (and then probably be calibrated by processes that are lost to history).

Tubes are very not exact compared to solid state devices— to replace a deflection yoke, it has to be of similar deflection angle and inductance, all the rest of the adjustment has to be done anyway.

It’s hard but pales in comparison to the impossibility manufacturing a new CRT vacuum tube.


> The coils in the deflection yoke are run at 24-100V.

They aren't the kV scale killer voltages, no. My memory was closer to 200, but sure. That's still "high voltage" for magnet wire, and a short will rapidly destroy the coil. I've had three different monitors go to that kind of failure. One day you turn them on and... nope.


> The glass is obviously fragile.

Ever broke one?

Like 2/3 of the weight is that front glass. It's _thick_.

When I was younger and dumber (well, at least younger) I tried breaking one. Took a running swing at the screen with a wrecking bar. It bounced off and all I got for my trouble was a sore shoulder.


The fun way to do it is to pull the deflection yoke off and shear the neck of the tube. I was pretty far away the only time I experienced somebody do that, but it sounded like a rifle round.

I believe the thick front (leaded) glass is to try to block the produced x-rays.

People were starting to get scared of the cancer those xrays might produce, and I suspect CRT manufacturers predicted a huge court settlement for cancers caused by TV's with insufficient shielding.

So far, it seems that hasn't materialized - not, I suspect because those xrays didn't cause cancer, but because it is simply impossible to produce any kind of evidence of cause/effect.


Only the oldest CRTs used leaded glass for the front, because leaded glass gradually turns brown on exposure to X-rays. More modern CRTs used glass with barium and strontium for X-ray shielding in the front. They still used leaded glass for the back and sides, presumably as a cost saving. I don't see any reason why you couldn't use the barium-strontium glass for the whole thing. Alternatively, CRTs could be made with ceramic bodies like Tektronix used to do.

The energy of the X-rays produced is limited by the CRT's acceleration voltage. The electrons get almost all of their energy from the field produced by the acceleration voltage. Electrons can produce photons when they hit matter, and one electron produces at most one photon, so by conservation of energy the X-ray cannot have greater energy. Smaller CRTs typically use low acceleration voltages, which means the X-rays are low energy and thus easy to block.


AFAIK, the shielding was also just very effective. "Soft" x-rays (below 50-100 kV or so) are rather easy to shield and what screens had was pretty overkill.

In the YouTube video they explain that CRTs have a layer of safety glass in front of the actual screen to protect viewers in the event that the screen implodes. You were actually trying to break through multiple pieces of glass! I've taken a crowbar to a broken CRT before for fun and can confirm that it takes a lot more effort than one might think.

It depends on the CRT. Some use steel bands wrapped around the edge of the faceplate and tightened to keep the glass in compression where it's strongest.

> Ever broke one?

Yes, drop one from a few feet, and the immense weight will do the work for you.


CRT phosphor chemistry was very sophisticated and mature, and there were many phosphors to choose from by the 1970s depending on the application. Maybe someday a flat panel screen will be produced with some warm and slow characteristics of CRTs without the drawbacks.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: