Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

So far what he's doing is working.



I think it’ll take years to find out if they’re really out of the dumps. And none of it will matter if the opposition wins and reverses all of his reforms.


This begs the question to define "working".

If you think like a short term, fiscal minded managerial sociopath, then yes. An easy excel exercise will show you "number goes down means world more gooder". But if you consider not just the cost but the quality and service provided as the actual value and measurable bottom line, you might not call it "working". Or second order reasoning, by considering governmental spending as economic stimulus ... libertarians are such a joke.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SWhDTdWND1I


Doing exactly the opposite was already lengthy tested…

You must be of the geniuses that run Argentina until now… with great results…

BTW: of course a throwaway account!


What would you suggest as an alternative? Argentina had run out of other people's money to spend.


Just adobt infinte growth capitalism, where you never run out of money. /s

I dont know how argentina ended up where it is today and yes inefficient bureaucracy is a worthy problem to go after but approaching it with an ideological mindset of "government is the problem" and trim indiscriminately (haha, ofc hit mostly poor working class) will somehow mysteriously miss the actual cause of institutional corruption and regulatory capture/inefficiency.

If the cause of inflation is partly, like in the west, caused by quasi monopolies/syndicates increasing prices, i would go after them first. There are many ways to do so.


government is the problem >> hit mostly poor working class)

You have obviously not seen the video. Also you have absolutely no idea what is going on there. Poor class in Argentina is bot working class, is unemployed.

> government is the problem

Who said that?! Over bloated state is the problem. If you cannot differentiate between state and government, you should really refrain from throwing opinions in state matters.

> the cause of inflation is partly, like in the west, caused by quasi monopolies/syndicates increasing prices

Tell me you have absolutely no idea of macroeconomics without saying it…


Ill bite one last time even though you didnt really expose own oppinions/suggestios/interpretations, just ad hominem.

> poor class in argentina

Afaik argentina didnt bet on manufactoring (like eg. china did), but resource and agricultural export, the primary economic sector, and thus had to struggle for an extended period of time with foreign lenders like the IMF (whos primary motive is to establish globalized access to resources in otherwise poor countries) during the economic turmoils since covid/ukrain/global inflation. This is a recipe for desaster for any export oriented country. Eg. germany will get hit similarly but only later due to its manufactoring. Strengthening inner consumption aswell as production is the key solution here.

> who said government is the problem

First, i am aware of the differences bt gov. and state. This phrase has been touted over the decades by many top tier politicians (to serve the private sector by sabotaging the public) like reagan, theatcher and even milei said it indirectly (and making a joke of himself by ignoring market failures and monopolies) [1] That you dont know this phrase does make you look a bit uneducated.

Telling me i have no idea about the causes of inflation but not even giving a hint of where and why is just cheap. Your first comment displayed severe botched reasoning, by framing me as one of those geniuses who have been running the country. You saw my throwaway handle and didnt really engage with counter arguments or looked at my comment history. You dont know me but yet you seem certain, like a typical superficial ideologue.

[1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fYmOQYckzL0&t=760s]




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: