Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> The HP50g that came much later is better in every respect

Absolutely not. The big fail on everything after the 48SX was the keyboard.

I could sit in an exam and punch buttons without even looking at the calculator. I could feel the positive "click" from every single keypress, and I don't remember my 48SX ever dropping a keypress for any basic operation.

By contrast, the 49/50 series had mushy keyboards that bounced or failed to register presses. I still have 3 48SX calculators that I can use--I sold all my 49/50 series.

The excellent keyboard is bar none the big feature that I can't duplicate with any modern calculator.

I really wish some mechanical engineer would do a teardown on the old HP calulators and analyze why the keyboards were so damn good.




The 48GX you mean, but yes. The keyboard on the 48 series was chef's kiss. The keyboard on anything after that was complete dogshit.

If it weren't for the crap keyboard I would still be using HP calculators to this day. I blame Carly Fiorina, personally.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: