Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

As you are not an American, let me educate on what that bill did.

Much like the "Inflation Reduction Act" which was a clean energy bill that had nothing to do with inflation, the bill did the exact opposite of what it claimed.

- It funded billions of dollars for the NGOs which were aiding illegal immigration

- It normalized and allowed historically high illegal levels of immigration (10x normal)

- It removed the standard process for adjudicating asylum by judges and made it part of the federal ICE

- Required the US to fund lawyers for all people who were charged with illegal immigration (12 million in the last 4 years)

- It gave $60 billion to Ukraine, 3x more than border security [1]

- It gave $14 billion to Israel, $10B to Gaza, $2B for conflicts in the Red Sea, $4B to Taiwan

During this period where 12 million (3.4% of US population) people have crossed the border for residency illegally, many of which have been flown in by the US federal government, the federal government has sued Texas repeatedly while they are trying to build a border wall. They have flown in percentages of whole populations to US swing states to try to build voters. And illegal immigrants count in the census which determines US electoral votes.

The reason the GOP voted against it is because it was a wishlist for the Democratic party. There is nothing more complicated about it than that. If the GOP was such fear mongers, as you say, they'd vote for a bill that ameliorated their concerns.

[1] https://www.reuters.com/world/us/us-senate-unveils-118-billi...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: