Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I wanted a new feature in our customer support console and the dev lead suggested I write a JIRA. I’m the CEO, so this is not my usual thing (and probably should not be). I told Claude what I wanted and pasted in a .js file from the existing project so that it would get a sense of the context. It cranked out a fully functional React component that actually looks quite nice too. Two new API calls were needed, but Claude helpfully told me that. So I pasted the code sample and a screenshot of the HTML output into the JIRA and then got Claude to write me the rest of the JIRA as well.

Everyone knows this was “made by AI” because there’s no way in hell I would ever have the time. These models might not be able to sit there and build an entire project from scratch yet, but if what you need is some help adding the next control panel page, Claude’s got your back on that.




You’re also the CEO so chances are the people looking at that ticket aren’t going to tell you the absolute mess the AI snippet actually is and how pointless it was to include it instead of a simple succinct sentence explaining the requirements.

If you’re not a developer chances are very high the code it produces will look passable but is actually worthless — or worse, it’s misleading and now a dev has to spend more time deciphering the task.


LoL, I really appreciate this comment. My team is very frank with me about code quality and they said Claude’s work looked pretty good — this time. But I’ll take your recommendation to heart for next time.


> Everyone knows this was “made by AI” because there’s no way in hell I would ever have the time.

Doubtful. A decent fraction of the people reading it will guess that you've wasted your time writing incoherent nonsense in the jira. Engineers don't usually have much insight into what the C suite are doing. It would be a prudent move to spend the couple of seconds to write "something like this AI sketch:" before the copy&paste.


> Everyone knows this was “made by AI” because ...

They should know because you told them so.

Having to decipher weird code only to discover it was not written by a human is not nice.


> dev lead suggested I write a JIRA. I’m the CEO, so this is not my usual thing (and probably should not be)

Fascinating point of view.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: