Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

That picture is hilarious, it's literally a clone of Apple's Mac line-up, right down to the wireless keyboard and Magic Trackpad.



When minimalism is a desired trait, it isn't far fetched to see competing firms to come up with similar designs.


I don't understand the belief that minimalist design is obvious and that everyone else totally would've designed it the same way.

It's almost like when someone walks up to a work of art and remarks that they easily could've done it themselves. Yeah, but you didn't.

Minimalist design is hard, and you're kidding yourself if you honestly think that Vizio's line of computers would've looked the same had Apple never existed.


I totally agree minimalist design is hard. But I believe that in a given genre, minimalist designs will converge. Not completely, but they will tend toward one another simply by virtue of having a common destination. In this case having the simplest laptop design that can still get the job done.

I think that Apple has done the grunt work of whittling away the bulk material toward a minimal design. It would be stupid of somebody else with the same goals to try to pretend that Apple's efforts bore no fruit (sorry, camp not intended) and ignore them.


Beyond that, Apple's minimalist design isn't manufactured by Apple -- so they tool up companies all over the world to make these Intel based 24" / 27" all in one computers. Obviously when Visio goes to a company that already built them for Apple, there is way lower production risk.


What is hilarious about stealing the best ideas from your competitors. It was Steve Jobs who pointed out that the best steal.

http://youtu.be/CW0DUg63lqU

"We have always been SHAMELESS about stealing great ideas" ... someone does it back to Apple and suddenly it is criminal (patent lawsuit fun) or laugh worthy because it looks similar?


Look, I'm a Mac user, but it's time we cut down with this, it makes me sick like the stupid kids on Gizmodo. The Vizio computers look good and they are not Mac clones. They picked the right ideas from Apple that nobody else picked up and they are doing a great job without looking the same.


Oh, the computers look very nice, but they're a direct response to what Apple puts out.

The Thin+Light machine is yet another Ultrabook that competes with the Macbook Air, keeping in mind that the Macbook Air was introduced in 2008 and the Ultrabook initiative started in 2011.

The All-in-One desktop is clearly a response to the iMac, right down to the Magic Trackpad.

I don't understand the stigma of pointing out these "inspirations".

However, I do admire the simplicity of Vizio's product line. If it were Dell, the laptop would be called something like the "Inspiron 14z Ultrabook™".




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: