Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

We didn't give freedom of the press to protect businesses from government scrutiny. We did it to keep free information flowing.

There's definitely some very hard and frank questions we need to ask if free information decides to focus on profits over communication.




The press is free to report on whatever they want. That freedom however is not a mandate that they must report on everything. Newspapers and other media companies have ALWAYS focused on profit. Nothing new there.

Plus in this day and age there is literally no restriction on the flow of public accessible information at least in the US. Even when it was tried recently (twitter, FB, YouTube) during the pandemic the public backlash to that attempts at information control was so great that it might literally sway this election.


> Nothing new there.

like most of the 21st century: Nothing new, just getting more efficient and less subtle with it. 20th century corruption would have had this announced way back in 2023 to make the timing not so obvious at the bare minimium instead of having editorial waste its time on a story that was pulled last minute.

>the public backlash to that attempts at information control was so great that it might literally sway this election.

but nothing much changed. I don't know if public outcry vs output was always this poor, but that certainly seems to have changed over the decades. Too many people uncomfortable enough to complain but not enough to get up and get out.


> but nothing much changed

Two of the three platforms (and the former CEO of one) have publicly admitted what was done at their companies was a mistake and the third has quietly reversed much of the topic controls around pandemic and vaccination content.

I’d say that is something.


(correction: no one "gave" press freedom. instead it is protected against government overreach. just like any other free speech. thank you.)




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: