Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> The IEEE has been riding this horse for a very long time

Well, there's your mistake right there. You're supposed to be riding an ox.

All this talk of oxen and horses got me curious about the PDF, so I went and took a look. It's really far worse than you've described.

I couldn't stomach it for too long, but here's some highlights:

(1) The first ~65 pages are about "requirements gathering." Page 60 offers up this gem of insight:

    Priority = ((Value * (1 - Risk)) / Cost
(2) The next hundreds of pages go through topics in sequence, like "Architecture" and "Design" (who knew they were different?). Naturally, "Security" is slapped on several hundred pages later.

I couldn't make it through the whole PDF, in all honesty. But I'm quite certain the soul of software engineering is nowhere to be found in there; they've eliminated it entirely and replaced it with stamp-collecting and checklists.




> like "Architecture" and "Design" (who knew they were different?)

O'Reilly, for one. ISBN 9781098134358's blurb says, "You'll learn the distinction between architecture and design..."




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: