Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Trailers have spoilers (both big and small), and/or are outright deceitful about the movie.

This feels like a strange take to me. Trailers are just advertisements for movies, and ads have to both inform about a product and hype it up. Do you also feel spoiled when you see an ad for a new burger because you’ve lost the mystery of what the toppings are? Do you feel deceived because the burger isn’t actually 3 feet wide like it was on the billboard?




Burgers aren't supposed to have plot developments and surprises like stories. That comparison makes no sense to me.

I would feel deceived if the ad showed off a beef burger and I got chicken. Or if I got some kind of meal that's the correct size but has a burger portion only 4cm wide. Now, sometimes trailers avoid big chunks of genre in service of not spoiling things, and that's a gambit that can work out, but most movies are a consistent genre and if they're trying to hype up a tiny portion of the movie because the rest is boring then that's not good.


> Do you also feel spoiled when you see an ad for a new burger because you’ve lost the mystery of what the toppings are?

Seeing the ad for the burger doesn't spoil much of the value that is the point of the burger.

Analogous spoiling would be to make the actual burger taste not as good, or to make the actual burger be less nutritious.


Have you ever watch films because of plot, not just for entertainment?


Time Trap (2017) is an excellent low budget sci-fi movie with a trailer that spoils the key plot elements. Had I watched the trailer before the movie, I certainly wouldn't have enjoyed Time Trap nearly as much.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: