Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

If Ukraine started a nuclear weapons program, they would be in violation of the NPT treaty. Sanctions and loss of Western support would be virtually guaranteed.



Ukraine is not bound by NPT because we are attacked by nuclear country. See text of NPT signed by Ukraine.

Moreover, Ukraine is post-nuclear country. We had nuclear weapons and we know how to produce more.


Ukraine is bound by the NPT until they exit it. That hasn’t happened so far.

Exiting it would lead to consequences from their allies, which they can’t afford.


It's not so simple, because Ukraine will join NPT when we will have security assurances from nuclear countries. It found recently, that security assurances, given to Ukraine, either a) broken, b) fake, so Ukraine may claim that the essential step is not completed yet.


Ukraine already joined the NPT, in the 1990s. That's a done deal.

Ukraine does not automatically leave the NPT just because Russia violated the Budapest Memorandum; such a mechanism linking the two does not exist. Ukraine would have to explicitly leave the NPT, which they will not do.


It's not a deal. It's cheat to disarm Ukraine. It's stupid to play fair game with cheaters.


But you understand this part, right?

Sanctions and loss of Western support would be virtually guaranteed.

Talk about biting the hand that feeds.

Seriously, this whole nuclear idea you're onto, while no doubt well-intentioned, is infinitely untenable for a whole bunch of plainly obvious reasons.


Ukraine may claim damages. Nuclear countries promised security assurances, then broke them. We have $1T in damages from war.

> Sanctions and loss of Western support would be virtually guaranteed.

This will be a good case to support the claims. Moreover, this support will be unnecessary for a nuclear country, because war will be ended very fast.


Except it's just not going to happen. I don't believe in the stupid propaganda (that gets repeated here almost every week) that Ukraine was manipulated into this war, by Boris or anyone else. Ukraine is entirely independent and makes its own choices.

But the simple fact is, it doesn't have unlimited control over its destiny in this particular regard, and pretending otherwise won't change that fact. It is entirely dependent on Western help at this point -- its benefactors are 1000 percent against any further nuclear proliferation, and are infinitely more concerned about that issue than they are about the borders of Ukraine, or Ukraine's survival in any other sense. They have no interest in the inevitable and far wider confrontation with Russia that would ensue from such recklessness -- and they just aren't going to allow it.


Yep, high dependency on Western help is a problem, which must be solved first.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: