Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Why? Politics. Fin.

The Japanese government has long managed the production of rice to keep market prices high for the farmers' sake and given subsidies to farmers to not fully utilize their production potential.

Covid hit and tanked the demand moreso than usual, so government policies shifted to further production (read: supply) reductions. Less supply in response to reduced demand equals maintained market prices.

Politics has not caught up in the post-covid era where demand from both domestic and international (including tourism) has recovered and surged. The supply is still mid-covid limited.

Why? Politics. Fin.




Even great farmers can go out of business with just one really bad year.

That's not really in your interest, either.

The free market people will say - oh, someone else will just come in and take over the farm.

Easier said than done.

I'm not saying Japan has the best system, but it's probably nowhere near as bad as you think.


As my grandfather (who along w/ his father-in-law, and my great-great-grandfather) was a farmer:

>Never complain about how farming is managed and paid for when your belly is full.


>I'm not saying Japan has the best system, but it's probably nowhere near as bad as you think.

I merely answered the Why? in the clickbaity article title.

As far as my thoughts on the policy, I think it's quite more reasonable than the far more popular western policy of letting the free market kill itself in a race to the bottom only to then be bought out by China.

The current rice shortage isn't a problem to do with the policy, it's how it's being handled.


And all western countries all doing same type of or similar enough subsidy. EU is built on it. Free market on food is only something pushed on lesser nations...


With the current high food prices, US taxpayers will be pleased to know that they will spend about 4 billion this year on ensuring the farmers don't grow too much food (this total is up from last year due to the inflation reduction act)


> With the current high food prices

High prices? 2022 is but a distant memory now. As a farmer, I haven't seen food prices this low, nominally, since the bottom of the mid-2010s crash, and if you account for inflation it doesn't look like food has ever been as cheap as it is right now!

Perhaps you mean the current high price of convenience? It does seem the grocery stores keep pushing prices higher even as the price of food keeps going down, down, down.


Partially true. Rising grocery prices and falling food commodity food prices. Where is all that money going? Look no further than corporate land ownership.


So be it. Votes talk, and neither party has margins to risk.


They don't care about votes outside of the swing states.

They care about the people who have been getting those billions for decades spending a small portion of it against them. Also they are concerned for their family members who happen to be upstanding people who landed in great jobs at charities owned by the people who get the billions to not feed people.


With the policy being active, non-stop, for 60 years (as opposed to temporary incentives to buoy farmers during a bad year) it's clearly politicking. Especially given the sleight-of-hand from the Abe administration (as mentioned in the article) where they claimed to kill the subsidy but actually only killed its limitations. In short - not sure why you've been downvoted.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: