Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Did the same thing about the same time - consulted with a composition professor, and he said that he didn't know anyone that was using Finale, so realized it was time to switch after using for 2 decades.

Agreed about the user-friendliness. Dorico is one of the most well thought-out, beautiful pieces of software I've seen. Really like the idea of modes - it's a bit complex at first, but think more software should do this. It's a really good way to separate features into different areas, to prevent the shotgun approach that most pieces of large software use, of just splattering features everywhere.

Still, end of an era.




Nice to read this. I was taught finale when I was in school in the early 00s. I went on to study music (as a performer) and my notational needs were covered by writing by hand or by lilypond).

I never though anything would actually threaten Sibelius or Finale, so reading about a new (and good) product has flbeen great.

Maybe it introduces new ways composers can make strange errors when writing music :)


Yeah, I had been a finale user for >10 years, and it was a slow deterioration on MakeMusic's part, but I got frog boiled by it.


frog-boiled, haha, good way to put it:)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: