Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Good job, you completely missed the point where I explain that pi, the constant, is a constant. And that "pi, if considered a ratio" (you know, that thing we did to originally discover pi) is not the same as "pi, the constant".

Language skills matter in Math just as much as they do in regular discourse. Arguably moreso: how you define something determines what you can then do with it, and that applies to everything from whether "parallel lines can cross" (what?) to whether divergent series can be mapped to a single number (what??) to what value the circle circumference ratio is and whether you can call that pi (you can) and whether that makes sense (less so, but still yes in some cases).



I haven’t missed your point. I’ve criticized it.

You’re treating your non-consensus definition not as a hypothetical, but as a fact. Your comment started with “fun fact”.


FWIW I enjoyed your original comment :)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: