Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I don't think elite cycling teams would be taking these supps if it caused that, do you?



I frankly don’t care what you believe, but I do care about the ability of the general population to understand reasoning and logic. To that end, please understand that what you’re arguing is not a counter-example like you seem to think it is. It’s an argumentum ad populum - you’re saying this must be true because elite cycling teams are doing it. This is not a proof. It’s not even evidence, you’re not even citing something specific enough to call it that.

Again, believe what you want just make sure you understand that you’re not making a sound argument.


You should probably look into the supplements I’m referring to before launching into a diatribe.


You seem to think that would affect my statement. Pay attention to what I’m actually saying. I have no opinion on the supplement. It’s still invalid reasoning regardless of whether the supplement is effective.


The dose makes the poison.


Also, have you heard of Lance Armstrong? Do you think elite cycling teams worry more about health or performance?

It's a sliding scale from no harm to performance benefits to death. Clearly they are intelligent and educated and those teams expend effort to stay to the left of death...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: