Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> There is an SEO-proof way to determine what the ranking of a site should be

This comment deserves a "my sweet summer child". Everything can be gamed; if you don't see how, then you really shouldn't be suggesting ideas.

How do you define an advertisement? How do you prevent downvote spam (if captchas worked, there wouldn't be bots/astroturfers on the Internet)? How will you fund your search engine?




> How do you define an advertisement?

Headless browser with uBlock Origin. Check programmatically how many ads were blocked on the page.


But many ads and crap today are actually not traditional ads. Don’t they count? If not, then gpt generated text ads or whatever will become more prevalent


> This comment deserves a "my sweet summer child".

I think being condescending really removes any impact from any point you want to make. After all, I posed this as an idle musing, not as a all-in venture, didn't I?

> Everything can be gamed; if you don't see how, then you really shouldn't be suggesting ideas.

If people are gaming the engine by avoiding all the penalties, then that's the exact sort of gaming I would like to see happen.

I mean, you have read through the rest of the thread, here, right?




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: