Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Well, the very next sentence after your quote is "It requires you to supply an OpenAI API key" which should answer your question.

Here's the default prompt:

> Return commands suitable for copy/pasting into \(shell) on \(uname). Do NOT include commentary NOR Markdown triple-backtick code blocks as your whole response will be copied into my terminal automatically.

> The script should do this: \(ai.prompt)




This doesn’t answer my question about watching the terminal contents. If I ‘cat’ a file, is the file’s contents sent to openai?


When you open Codecierge in the toolbar sidebar, it warns you with this:

> Everything that happens in your terminal while Codecierge is running will be sent to OpenAI. Don't send them confidential information!

And when you check the box "Run commands automatically" it shows you this popup:

> This lets an AI completely control your computer. It could delete your files, do something stupid or dangerous, or lead to the downfall of humanity. Proceed with caution.

Though that's the Codecierge feature "Toolbelt -> Show Toolbelt" + Toggle "Codecierge" toolbelt window. "Run commands automatically" is hilarious.

The simpler Edit -> Engage AI (Cmd+Y) feature seems much more useful for day to day stuff and it doesn't send terminal contents to OpenAI. e.g. Cmd+Y -> "Extract foo.tar in verbose mode".

That renders the LLM's response command in a small pane and you have to Shift+Enter to go ahead and paste it into the terminal. That's really nice.


> Don't send them confidential information!

Most of what I do in a terminal is confidential. I find it scary and also funny that in the age of data laws, privacy policies, data leaks, etc, someone thought this is an acceptable workflow.


For someone working on their personal projects for which they can make decisions about visibility, why wouldn't it be an acceptable workflow?


Absolutely fine for that workflow.

Make sure to add a note to the project’s privacy policy that user data is sent to openai.


> "Run commands automatically" is hilarious.

Yeah they should make it so it mocks the user for attempting to set it to true and explain in select, direct, simple to understand words why that's a dumb idea and that obviously the user didn't read the disclaimer.


Yeah, it kinda seems like a feature a developer would implement for fun but I don't see much practical use for it off the top of my head.

In the sidebar Codecierge convo they do give you a "Copy code" button whenever it detects code blocks. I think it'd be more practical to also add a "Paste and run" shortcut to each code block. i.e. A little "Play" button.

Aside, Codecierge doesn't seem to read the terminal contents like it says it should. If you ask it any questions or reference anything in your terminal, like an error in response to a command it gave you, it doesn't seem to have that context.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2025 batch! Applications are open till May 13

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: