Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

To each their own. I personally didn't get Scarlett Johansson vibes from the voice on the GPT-4o demo (https://openai.com/index/hello-gpt-4o/) even though I'm a huge fan of hers (loved Her, loved Jojo Rabbit, even loved Lucy, and many many others) and have watched those and others multiple times. I'd even say I have a bit of a celebrity crush.

To me it's about as close to her voice as saying "It's a woman's voice". Not to say all women sound alike but the sound I heard from that video above could maybe best be described and "generic peppy female American spokesperson voice"

Even listening to it now with the suggestion that it might sound like her I don't personally hear Scarlett Johansson's voice from the demo.

There may be some damming proof where they find they sampled her specifically but saying they negotiated and didn't come to an agreement is not proof that it's supposed to be her voice. Again, to me it just sounds like a generic voice. I've used the the version before GPT-4o and I never got the vibe it was Scarlett Johansson.

I did get the "Her" vibe but only because I was talking to a computer with a female voice and it was easy to imagine that something like "Her" was in the near future. I also imagined or wished that it was Majel Barrett from ST:TNG, if only because the computer on ST:TNG gave short and useful answers where as ChatGPT always gives long-winded repetitive annoying answers




200%. I listened to both, and don't think it was "her" enough.


OpenAI confirmed it by removing the voice immediately after Johansson's lawyers reached out


That's not confirmation. That's called prudence.


Ask to use Alice's likeness in my product, get declined. Ask again. Debut product, users say "this sounds a lot like Alice". The day my product releases, I make a public statement referencing a movie Alice starred in. When Alice asks how I made my product, I delete all access to the product.

How else am I supposed to interpret this?


"better safe than sorry"

- any legal team, ever, in the history of the universe


Have you met any corporate lawyers? Its all about CYA




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: