Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

This is small potatoes.

Hertz has been actually triggered false arrets of its own customers -some going to jail - due to poorly implemented software logic....[1]

And no one at hertz is going to jail [2]. They are settling as usual.

[1] https://www.cbsnews.com/news/hertz-claims-false-arrests/

[2] https://www.npr.org/2022/12/06/1140998674/hertz-false-accusa...




With all of the pitch fork and torches being gathered, who is at fault to point the gather crowd to go after? Is it Hertz for accepting faulty software, or the software devs for designing such broken code and passing it off as production ready? Where was this program made? How many boats will be required to ferry the gathering crowd to the offshored lands?

Also, at what point do police stop accepting "stolen" car reports from Hertz? This is such a failure on so many levels, why is Hertz the only ones receiving the hate?


> who is at fault to point the gather crowd to go after?

Ultimately I'll point the fault at the district attorney, as they are the ones who decide what is prosecuted and what is not.

They take unsubstantiated allegations from hertz and put people to jail, but at the same time don't lift a finger to prosecute the clearly guilty corporations for fraud. So yes, while mistakes are made all around, the ultimate guilty party is the district attorney.


Have there been any convictions in any of these false cases due to poorly written software? I get being arrested and detained in jail for any length of time is total bullshit. Unless these people cannot post bail after being arraigned, that should be the end of it. Once a defense attorney challenges the case, the DA should be dropping charges. If the DA continues to prosecute, what jury is convicting? So this "going to jail" sounds like it's getting conflated from held until arraignment versus serving time after being found guilty


What gave you the impression anyone was confused about that? You just think being taken to jail is no big deal?


"Ultimately I'll point the fault at the district attorney,"

For it to be the DA's fault, lots of other things have failed first. So I don't really see how the DA is that relevant. If devs failed by making software that doesn't work in a way that the company using it cannot keep track of their inventory in a way that makes it look like their customers have not returned items in a way that looks like it has been stolen so that they can make a report to the police who cannot properly investigate which results in someone being arrested but never charged does not make any sense for a DA to receive any blame in this situation at all. (jeebus that must be the longest sentence I've ever typed).


> So I don't really see how the DA is that relevant.

Because only they are the one with the power to actually act on this and pursue charges. They are supposed to validate the facts before proceeding, but here they just take the word of hertz without any evidence (since hertz's systems are messed up as you say so they don't have any idea what's where) and run with it, accusing innocent people.

The DA is the one with the power to tell hertz to produce credible evidence or go pound sand. But they don't.


so by all of this, you are implying that DAs are taking these cases to trial and winning. this is where I am not familiar. what jury has heard one of these cases and convicted? what DA has brought a case to trial. where is this happening. you seem to have some form of awareness that this is the case. share it so we can all see where this is happening.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: