Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I didn’t mention tensorflow or TF Lite? IREE is a different technology, it is essentially a compiler/VM for MLIR. Since JAX exports MLIR, you can run JAX on any platform supported by IREE (which is basically any platform from embedded hardware to datacenter GPUs). It is less mature than ONNX at this point, but much more promising when it comes to deploying on edge devices.



> I didn’t mention tensorflow or TF Lite

I know.

OP didn't mention JAX, or IREE.

I avoided having a knee-jerk "Incorrect, the thing you are talking about is off-topic" reaction because it's inimical to friendly conversation.

Mentioning ONNX and llama.cpp made it clear they were talking about inference. In that context, TF Lite isn't helpful unless you have TF. JAX is irrelevant. IREE is expressly not there yet[1] and has nothing to do with Google.

[1] c.f. the GitHub "IREE is still in its early phase. We have settled down on the overarching infrastructure". From a llama.cpp/ONNX/local inference perspective, there's little more than "well, we'll get MLIR, then we can make N binaries for N model x arch x platform options." Doesn't sound so helpful to me, but I got it easy right now, models are treated as data instead of code in both ONNX and llama.cpp. I'm not certain that's the right thing long-term, ex. it incentivizes "kitchen sink" ML frameworks, people always want me to add a model to the library, rather than use my library as a dependency.


Speaking as someone who deploys ML models on edge devices - having the MLIR and being able to make binaries for different platforms is terrifically useful! You’re often supporting a range of devices (e.g. video game consoles, phones, embedded, etc) and want to tune the compilation to maximize the performance for your deployment target. And there are a lot of algorithms/models in robotics and animation that simply won’t work with ONNX as they involve computing gradients (which torch cannot export, and the gradients ONNXRuntime give you only work in training sessions, which aren’t as widely). supported.

Also, if you have JAX you can get TF and therefore TFLite. And IREE is part of the OpenXLA project, which Google started.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: