Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Resilient, but also infamous for being hard to modify. Our security team has a massive set of automation written in Perl, and it's slowly being replaced, not because it fails, but because the original author left; and when we need to modify it, it's generally easier to rewrite in another language than figure out what it's doing.

Also, you need to manually install all the dependencies on your system before you can use it (whereas "go build" will just go get everything for you); and there are no test cases (whereas "go test" makes it natural to write unit tests as you're developing it, and keep those after whatever feature you're working on is complete). Rust is the same of course. All that adds up to, "More useful to rewrite than to modify".




> also infamous for being hard to modify

Perl is not forcing any particular style. If you don't care about maintainability you can quickly hack code which will solve the problem but will be hard to understand/update. If you do you can use tools like Perl::Critic to enforce a certain style. And lack of documentation and comments (which makes maintenance harder) IMHO not language specific problem at all.

> and there are no test cases

Modules on CPAN had tests back when open-source libraries in other languages didn't have any. It's not hard to write tests for Perl code but if you don't have time to write them or it is not a priority it's unfair to blame the language.


It's a bit unfair to compare Perl and Rust/Go, they are massively better languages with massively better tooling that fix an IMHO different problem.

Perl is IMHO for glue code, text processing, and that's it. It is not for large, structured programs - the threshold is IMHO ~10k lines.


Perl pioneered language-specific package management with CPAN, why can't you use that?


Is there a way to hand cpan a perl executable, and have it automatically download all the appropriate dependencies?

So far for me it's worked like "Run command -> get failure -> search on CPAN, install -> repeat 4-5x".

For golang it works like "go install <url> -> run command".

EDIT: And to compile something on my macbook and put it on a shared Linux box for other people on the team to use, it's "GOOS=linux go build -o $BNAME_linux && scp $BNAME_linux user@host:bin/$BNAME", done and dusted.

Look, perl was an amazing thing for its day. As you say, they pioneered new language ecosystem features. But that was all in the 90's and early 2000's; since then other systems have built on that and pioneered even better ecosystem features, so that moving back to perl is a big step backwards.


This is a non-issue for Stow though because it’s managed by your distro’s package manager.




Consider applying for YC's W25 batch! Applications are open till Nov 12.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: