Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

We should repeal the National Security Act of 1947.

Nuclear weapons have proliferated to nine nations around the world since the passage of that act. The production of nuclear armaments is clearly limited by political will and industrial power, not knowledge.

The act protects a foreign policy establishment that has abused its power to conduct dirty tricks against other nations for decades in order to keep American elites rich and in power.

No one is going to invade the American homeland, given the vast oceans separating us from the rest of the world. Repealing that act and removing the foreign policy establishment from power would unwind our vast empire abroad and greatly improve our relations with other nations.

I would prefer that we do this cleanly, but unfortunately I think our empire will suffer a far messier fall from power over the coming decades. Empires at this stage flail wildly in their military adventures.




Even accepting what I think are very inaccurate perceptions of US and world international relations needs, what would we replace it with?

Also, back to our topic, how do you handle secrecy? Again, obviously some things must be secret, some things public.

Absolute answers are too easy - nothing, everything, destroy the entire foreign policy establishment, etc. We need real ideas and answers.


There's no need to "destroy" the entire foreign policy establishment. We just need to force them to operate without the secrecy and privileges they presently enjoy and exploit so they can be subject to the democratic process.

Surely this is better than to suffer more wars like Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan, etc.

EDIT (apparently my responses are being throttled): In response to wolverine876's question below, "How would secrecy be managed?"

We don't need any secrecy or statecraft. We're so large and established that we can do everything out in the open. Russia and China know where our missiles, bases, ships and submarines are, and we know where their are. The only people in the dark about everything are the citizens in both countries.

A similar argument was made against Linux when open-source was new. It turns out you don't need any closed source code at all to run a successful project.


I'm still not sure what solution you are suggesting. How would secrecy be managed?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: