Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

They will still have to have their app notarized (basically signing the app). Apple can revoke certificates at any time.

After the first 1 million installations they will be charging a Core Technology Fee, which is a flat €0.50 per install. Every installation still needs to talk with an Apple server it seems (not 100% sure on this), so Apple should be able to track it.

An app like Spotify is using a bunch of Apple’s technology in their iOS app. UIKit and CoreAudio almost for certain.




If Apple has to approve of every app, then what changed?

I thought the whole point of alternative appstores is to do away with that?


In theory:

* App approval is a lower bar to pass than App Store approval.

* Alternative stores can have different policies for which types of content are prohibited or for how monetization works. For example, they could allow R18 media, or accept payment via additional payment methods.

* Alternative stores can be cheaper.

* Alternative stores could also enforce their own rules that are superior to Apple's - for example you could have a store that guarantees everything on it is open-source and has been fuzzed, and they could promote that on some sort of a security basis.

But yes in practice "Apple still gets to decide whether you can put apps on iDevices, and you have to pay them for that" does defeat a lot of the purpose of the DMA.


If the EU is serious about breaking up the monopoly, the notarization requirement is what they will go after.


You're basically asking the EU to compel Apple to open up their platform and all their R&D that goes into their toolchains to developers for free at no charge.


I'm doing no such thing.

Apple should be completely free to charge as they like for their toolchain.

But other toolchains will arise. And Apple's doesn't half stand on the shoulder of others.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: