Ok. Here is a lesson on forums. The comment thread you replied to is full of a guy trying to use a strawman argument. Except he stuck with the same one. You came along with a new strawman argument. So because you replied to a series of strawman arguments with a new attempt at a strawman arguments I wrote my comment in context of where it is in the thread of replies. So I congratulated you on being different. However, I then went on to shame you for using a strawman argument in the first place.
The lesson here, is always remember context. The point at which you start your input is surrounded with the context of before it. So if you were closer to the start the context of the previous strawman attempts wouldn't have been in play.