Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Indeed. Here is an excellent & maintained summary of the lengthening terms (from 14 years to more than a century) and its effects: https://web.law.duke.edu/cspd/publicdomainday/2023/shrinking...



Now this is really sad. This is why we don't have nice things.

I believe the "natural" state of the society where we can build on each others work, but copyrights make that practically impossible.

It lowers the quality of art significantly (I do believe that most art pieces could be significantly improved, but we can't do that).

It lowers the quality of cars, electronics, and other products, also their reparability from 100% to 0% or so, as they constantly discontinue past products, and make them shittier, and they prohibit 3rd party to make replacement parts, and we can do nothing against it.

And it allows rent-seeking behaviour, for example we gave Intel a hundred of billions of dollars or so, because the prevented other companies to produce x86 compatible chips, and they could get away with ridiculous profits. This would be illegal if Intel was a 'monopoly', but the same rent-seeking and abusing the market is not illegal since Intel is not a monopoly. Or countless other examples.

The article states that we almost developed a sane society where we could build and sell whatever we wanted, and use whatever we found (even if it was made by an other person), but the exact opposite happened. The article does not mention the reasons.


> Now this is really sad.

Yes. The worst part is our current effectively-infinite copyright length is a very recent invention, but it's already taken root as the-way-things-are. Imagine a world where copyright lasts 28 years max. How different would our culture be? All of our early computing history would be 100% freely available, no questions asked. Windows XP would be nearing the end of its copyright term. This is the way things were for centuries, right up until 1978 when things started going off the rails.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: