Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Can someone just summarize what compounds are thought to be responsible?



http://www.cbc.ca/documentaries/doczone/2008/disappearingmal...

Bisphenol A (found mostly in hard colored plastics) is becoming particularly non grata (update: in Canada) these days.

Edit: according to the article it's also "the de facto lining used in food cans". Wow.


Sounds like the probem is stuff made out of plastic. Is that a reasonable summary?


From what I could tell in the video, bisphenol a's a petroleum derivative that is used to harden polycarbonates. The other one, pthalates (also a petroleum derivative) is used to soften PVC. So technically, not made out of plastic, but used to make plastic.

Edit: Realized I misread your comment. Yes, the problem is with some plastic products, which use these chemicals (but not all, since the video mentioned that one hospital using safe plastic products).


I have the impression it's some plastics but not all. A rule of thumb many people up here use is to avoid plastics with recycling number 6 (polystyrene) or 7 (polycarbonate). These are said to be the worst.

Alex, does the film contain specific recommendations to consumers? (Normally I hate using the word "consumer" to mean "citizen" but in this case it could hardly be more accurate.)


I didn't watch the last few min of the film, but here is a good list of things to avoid:

http://www.sailhome.org/Concerns/BodyBurden/Burdens/Phthalat...

Realistically it will be impossible to completely avoid the stuff until it's made illegal.


Given that the list includes water, I'd have to agree!


Somewhat--but phthalates are also in cosmetics, carpeting, deodorants, and many other household items.


"Bisphenol A (found mostly in hard colored plastics) is becoming particularly non grata these days."

Not in the United States.


Funny, my comment originally said something about Canada and I cut it out for brevity. I'll add it back. (Actually, it's not funny at all. The industry's argument appears to be: "But if we don't poison people, how will we make all those shiny plastic bottles?" With the fallback position: "How about if we just don't poison babies? Will that do?")


Some food storage containers, water bottles, and the like are advertising "BPA-free."


You left out phthalates, which are also in plastics, but are not the same thing as BPA.


Phthalates, which are in products made of PVC plastics (like the pipes) which includes childrens toys but are also found in tons of other things like cosmetics, deodorants, and fragranced products.

Bisphenol A (BPA) is the other major offender. Many companies are at least removing from baby bottles and teethers now.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bisphenol_A

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phthalate


Phthalates and bpa.


Didn't watch the video, but I have also heard bad things about soy, which is also in a lot of processed food.


Yes, soy protein isoflavones are phytoestrogens. Males should limit soy consumption.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: