Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

On the other hand, children generally love ice cream and hate broccoli. They'll eat so much ice-cream that it makes them sick.

It depends on what you mean by "worth watching".




Adults love ice cream and "hate"* broccoli too, in general. They simply choose to eat one over the other based on external input.

You can't apply necessity to art. I don't have to eat some shitty art-film to survive.

* - Hate is probably an overloaded word anyways. I don't know many kids who genuinely "hate" broccoli, they just think eating broccoli means they won't get ice cream because they don't have rational thought processes and can't think/imagine beyond the next fifteen minutes. Adults can, and so the distaste is less extreme, because they can have ice cream on their cheat day. But obesity rates would show that nothing really changes, in how much they "like" things.


> Adults love ice cream and "hate"* broccoli too, in general. They simply choose to eat one over the other based on external input.

Of course it's impossible for one person's evidence to refute what happens "in general", but either this isn't true for me, or I don't understand what you mean. I love broccoli. I don't hate ice cream, but I certainly wouldn't eat it every day, which I'd be happy to do for broccoli. I don't think I'm responding in any significant way to external factors, only to eating one regularly making me feel better than eating the other regularly. I don't imagine my experience to be universal, but nor do I imagine it to be very rare.


The point you're refuting is a sidenote, at best. Thus, the asterisk and footnote aspect of it.

However, I addressed your point:

> obesity rates would show that nothing really changes, in how much they "like" things.

If everyone loved healthy food and hated treats, obesity rates wouldn't be so high, and Frito-Lay wouldn't be one of the most profitable food companies in the world. Obviously, no general claim is universal.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: