Yeah it’s such a weird critique from GP, who elsewhere acknowledge that she had “credibility” for a “nuanced” perspective. The reason people thought that is that she was actually often vocally critical of China as well!

Ironically you have proved my point with the very tweets that you posted.

It's not illegal for people in China to get mad when they see a person randomly assaulted on the street, or mad about things in general that are happening in China.

That's not the kind of stuff that will get you silenced.

Instead, it is other topics. For example, if the perpetrator in those tweets had happened to be a high up/protected government official, in the national party, well then I assure you that you would have seen some suspicious silence.

Censorship in China is much more complicated than the false position that has been ascribed to me here, which would be "nobody in China can be upset about anything".