Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It’s rather when the industry can keep fighting for 50 years to save pennies over lives, and faces no punishment for it.



You'd think some of the trucking companies would do it just for publicity, if it was cheap enough.

Then again, cars could all come with roll cages and five-point harnesses, and they don't, so there's some limit to safety equipment.


>Then again, cars could all come with roll cages and five-point harnesses, and they don't, so there's some limit to safety equipment.

No roll cages historically was the result of no federal safety belt law. Roll cages are great until an un-belted occupant has their head hit the cage. "Second collision." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_impact_(safety)

At this point New Hampshire is the last remaining holdout on state safety belt laws. Live free or die (in a car crash).

Even then, you still have the issue of noncompliance. Automakers don't want to end up on 60 Minutes in an episode about how their "safer car" kills some people, because some of those people were un-belted in a crash. Numbers are all over the place for people not wearing their seat belt, but it's somewhere in the neighborhood of 1 in 10.


Nobody is going to hear about someone not wearing a seatbelt dying in an accident and blame it on the manufacturer of the vehicle.


Most modern passenger car passenger cells don't need roll cages because their passenger safety cells are properly engineered, and because crash safety is much more comprehensive, with wheels and suspension components designed to intentionally fail and crumple in a crash so they aren't pushed into the passenger cell.

A ton of cars pass Euro-NCAP and IIHS crash and rollover tests with flying colors.

Roll cages were a Thing because, well, this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fPF4fBGNK0U

Obviously not every car is up to snuff, especially at the bottom end of the market. You couldn't pay me to drive a current production GM, Ford, Suzuki, Mitsubishi, etc compact sedan.

5-point harnesses aren't really that necessary at 0-60mph speeds in a vehicle with modern airbags; the fifth strap is mostly for anti-submarining but a number of manufacturers have produced seats that are anti-submarining and anti-submarining dashboard design (both material and shape) is a thing as well.

All of it's possible, it's just a lot of car companies are cheap and consumers don't really shop based on stuff like "is there an anti-submarining design to the dash."


A well-built roll cage should prevent the very issue that is under discussion here (it should shove the truck up or the car down, not decapitate the driver).

But that's clearly not very desirable.


What exactly do you do with the publicity? You're a B2B company. I've never heard of someone calling up Safeway and asking if they use SafeGuards Trucking over RideHighOrDie Trucking. Literally zero incentive.


B2B companies have customers.

And two really big trucking companies are UPS and FedEx, along with Amazon, too. Walmart, also.


The article points out that one company did indeed do it for PR reasons.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: