Again, I agree with everything you are saying in your edit. It's just not what my CPA is saying the actual tax code says anymore.
Honestly my main reason for starting this discussion was a) to see if anyone else's professional advice (e.g. from a CPA) was different, and b) to hopefully drum up awareness so maybe in some roundabout fashion this gets changed.
That's all fair. You're pretty persistently knocking down alternative interpretations as "not what my CPA said", though. Maybe just let them be and let people draw their own conclusions since this is a discussion. Idk. People are trying to help out and you just keep saying "not what my CPA said". Obviously we should be having this discussion with your CPA, then (:
If anyone knows of a CPA who thinks this isn't how it works now, please let me know their contact info, as I would love to pay them to advise me on this and get a third opinion.
You may want to consider consulting with an actual tax lawyer, not just a CPA. CPAs are not necessarily experts on all the implications of recent changes to tax law.
Honestly my main reason for starting this discussion was a) to see if anyone else's professional advice (e.g. from a CPA) was different, and b) to hopefully drum up awareness so maybe in some roundabout fashion this gets changed.