Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

They do however reside on server hosting the link



No, that's not entirely true. I don't have to use a service like bit.ly to send one of these messages. And further, I could just as easily use _any_ or _many_ services. Since the technology is fundamentally browser-to-browser kind of distributed concept, it's just the URL shortening that's not SOPA compliant.

There's also several ways to obscure the impact of SOPA on the URL shortening anyway. For instance, if several services use the same hash algorithm for representing URLs, they can be used interchangeably (if you post the URL to all of them). Further, you can always set up your own temporary shortening service as well.


* No, that's not entirely true. I don't have to use a service like thepiratebay.org to send one of these files. And further, I could just as easily use _any_ or _many_ trackers inside my torrent. *

Altered to convey another point. Naturally, it would be quite difficult to "embed" a feature length movie into a single url, but if one was to split the file into chunks like torrent transferring does, or simply a multi-part rar like newsgroups still do, it enables each chunk to be more manageable.

I do agree with you though, but I think the reason that a service like this if changed in such a way to be user-friendly for file sharing, not just document sharing, would be able to get around a lot of the pitfalls a torrent tracker (for example) would have if it's DNS lookup was blocked (which aren't many) is due to the simple fact that SOPA is written in a way that assumes all IP addresses and DNS names are statically tied together and slow to alter, not that I can have a new domain name in a matter of minutes that resolves to my existing server. Even more so if the final URL hash was nothing more than a common and known algorithm, like base64, that one could easily plug into a basic desktop app and get the same result.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: