Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

that movie is fiction

probably neither any kind of fiction, nor any kind of movies, but least of all fictional movies, are a good source for information about scientific facts, toxicology, or risk assessment




It is a dramatization of a real story, one that happened to be testified to in congress not long before the movie came out. Please take people in good faith.


i don't think the grandparent poster is posting in bad faith, i just think they're getting their information about that real story from an intentionally unreliable source

movies lie to you on purpose to manipulate your emotions

there are lots of reliable information sources about pollution risks, like mmwr, the cochrane collaboration, msds, toxicology textbooks, wikipedia, epa assessments, and so on

there is no need to make yourself dumber by making life decisions contingent on beliefs you acquired from movies


What in the movie was false?


this is a ridiculous question

i am not going to subject myself to hours of manipulative propaganda for which truth is not even a consideration in order to write a 'rebuttal' nobody wants to read, thus implicitly affirming all the errors that i missed or that didn't seem important enough to mention

dramatizations are works of fiction

literally everything in them is false with the occasional exception

every word, every facial expression, every event, every chemical reaction, every purchase, every article of clothing, every motivation

the exceptions where they say something objectively true are enumerable; the falsehoods are not

don't base your beliefs or life decisions on fiction

finding out what is true and making good choices are hard enough without deliberately sabotaging the process


this is a ridiculous question

I think it's a perfectly reasonable response to your assertion that "movies lie to you on purpose to manipulate your emotions" in order to defend the GP comment.

If that's a ridiculous question, it's only because your assertion was equally ridiculous given the context of the thread.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: