Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Scientology, herbalife, and other obvious scams have persisted. I think crypto people love getting defrauded, and as long as they enjoy it there won't be much pressure to prosecute.



I Dunn if it is fair to include Scientology in that.

Other than the amounts of money involved, it clearly is a religion.


And in general religions are in business of extracting money from people and using it for their own means. Scientology is not any different from any other. Including the mainstream Christian cults...


And their means both as determined by their doctrine and expressed by their history vary greatly. In the US religions have been legally defined (a subject of much debate historically) as they are given tax and regulatory exemptions and often public funding. Here’s a good read on the topic from 1969:

https://scholarship.law.nd.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3...

I’m curious, are there specific ones your referring to, or do you consider all mainstream denominations of Christianity cults?


Wait is the government a religion?


You may want to check the validity of the syllogism.


The US government is made up of 4 religions: Democrat, Republican, MAGA and Bernie Sanders.


I don't understand the modding down. Does someone want to explain why Scientology is different than, say, the major Christian religions? Or Islam?


Here’s my understanding:

In Christianity, god extorts adherence through the revelation that there’s eternal life after death and the threat of eternal damnation as punishment for insubordination. The requirements to enter Heaven are acknowledgment and acceptance of Jesus’ crucifixion as atonement for your transgressions (and possibly repentance).

In Islam, god extorts adherence through the revelation that there’s eternal life after death and the threat of eternal damnation as punishment for insubordination. The requirements to enter Paradise are not explicitly defined (aside possibly through dying in a Jihad) so strict adherence is arguable more crucial than in Christianity.

In Scientology, god extorts adherence by eliciting confessions of past transgressions on videotaped counseling sessions and threatening public exposure for insubordination, among other tactics.


At least Islam and Christianity funded art, architecture and to some extent science and literacy.

Disclosure: I'm agnostic asymptotically approaching atheist




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: